Recordings with Mills Blue Rhythm Band and Red Allen

The question of whether Willie Humphrey recorded with Mills Blue Rhythm Band is still unsettled, but common sense suggests that he did. While we don't know the exact dates of his tenure with the band, he has said that he was with the band for about six months, beginning in December, 1935. As I said in my last post, the band recorded three times during that period, on December 20, 1935, January 21, 1936, and May 20, 1936. 

The standard discography of early jazz, Brian Rust's Jazz Records 1897 - 1942, does not list Humphrey in the band at all. Tom Lord's discography has Humphrey joining for the December 20, 1935 session, but at least in my edition (Version 17) it's unclear if Lord meant to list Humphrey for the next two sessions. In any case, I've listened to all the relevant recordings, and here are the Mills Blue Rhythm Band recordings on which I think the clarinet work is likely by Willie.

From December 20, 1935:

Blue Mood  - This tune features a long low-register melody statement by the clarinet after the introduction. The clarinetist has a liquid, but slightly reedy tone. It sounds like Willie to me.

Yes! Yes! - There is an eight-bar clarinet solo at 2:23. The final cascading final phase in particular makes me think that it's Humphrey.

From May 20, 1936:

St. Louis Wiggle Rhythm - Another eight-bar clarinet solo, at 2:01. The articulation, especially in the last two measures, sounds very "Humphrey-esque."

There is also a short, four-bar alto sax solo on "Midnight Ramble" (from January 21, 1936) that could possibly be played by Willie, who of course doubled on alto with the Mills band. There really isn't enough recorded evidence in terms of Humphrey's saxophone playing to make a determination. The alto solos from May 20 are surely by Tab Smith. 

There is one confirmed recorded glimpse of Humphrey's clarinet from the Mills days. In 1935, Red Allen began a series of small-band recordings for the Vocalion label, and on April 1, 1936, he included his Mills bandmate Willie Humphrey in the personnel. Willie mostly plays background notes on alto saxophone, but he gets one two-bar break in "Every Minute of the Hour," presumably to give Allen time to take down his trumpet and prepare for his vocal chorus. But wow - what a break! Willie soars from the top to the bottom of the clarinet's range, using extremely fast note values. The break comes at the 34-second mark.